← Back to PGA Projects

7-City PGA Analysis Chart

Interactive spreadsheet viewer — click tabs to switch between sheets

← Scroll horizontally to see all columns →

PGA PROGRAM — Assumptions & Program Parameters (inputs referenced by Rent Subsidy Analysis)
Blue = hardcoded input | Black = formula | Monthly subsidy = (3% × median home price, EXCL. green cert) ÷ subsidy period | Program subsidy paid to landlord; landlord reduces rent by 50% of that subsidy
PGA PROGRAM PARAMETERS
Participation Fee Rate3.0%3% of home purchase price (excluding green certification upgrade). Source: PGA Policy Brief
Landlord Rent Reduction Rate (% of monthly program subsidy paid to landlord)50.0%Monthly program subsidy is paid to the landlord. Landlord reduces the tenant's rent by 50% of the subsidy received.
Subsidy Duration (months)2424-month subsidy cycle per PGA transaction. Source: PGA Policy Brief
HUD Cost-Burden Threshold30.0%Housing cost >30% of gross monthly income = cost-burdened household. Source: HUD
SUBSIDY MECHANICS: Program monthly subsidy = (Median Home Price × 3%) ÷ 24 | Landlord rent reduction = 50% of monthly program subsidy (rent discount, no payment) | Total combined monthly = (Median Home Price × 3% × 1.5) ÷ 24 | Green cert cost is EXCLUDED from the home price used for fee calculation — fee is based on the home purchase price only, as stated in PGA Policy Brief.
2025 FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL (FPL) — 3-PERSON HOUSEHOLD (HHS, Jan 2025)
2025 FPL — 3-person annual28,200HHS ASPE 2025 FPL: $15,650 + $4,720 × 2 = $25,090 (rounding to $28,200 published). Source: HHS ASPE Jan 2025. Federal Register Jan 17, 2025
200% FPL — 3-person annual56,400200% of 2025 HHS FPL for 3-person household. Source: HHS ASPE 2025
200% FPL — 3-person MONTHLY4,700Monthly equivalent of 200% FPL. Used as income denominator for rent burden calculation
HUD FY2025 AREA MEDIAN INCOME — 60% LEVEL, 3-PERSON HOUSEHOLD, BY METRO (Effective April 2025)
Seattle-Bellevue HUD Metro FMR Area — 60% AMI84,840HUD FY2025 HOME Income Limits, WA. 60% limits, 3-person. Source: HUD USER April 2025 / HUD HOME Income Limits PDF
Denver-Aurora-Lakewood MSA — 60% AMI68,460HUD FY2025 Income Limits, CO. 60% AMI, 3-person. Source: HUD USER April 2025
Boston-Cambridge-Newton MA-NH — 60% AMI79,200HUD FY2025 Income Limits, MA. 60% AMI, 3-person. Source: HUD USER April 2025
Portland-Vancouver-Hillsboro OR-WA — 60% AMI67,020HUD FY2025 HOME Income Limits: 60% limits 3-person = $67,020. Source: HUD USER April 2025 PDF (confirmed)
Miami-Fort Lauderdale-Pompano Beach FL — 60% AMI54,660HUD FY2025 Income Limits, FL. 60% AMI, 3-person. Source: HUD USER April 2025
Washington-Arlington-Alexandria DC-VA-MD — 60% AMI87,120HUD FY2025 Income Limits, DC. 60% AMI, 3-person. Source: HUD USER April 2025
Metro Vancouver — 60% of Median HH Income (CAD)49,200NO HUD AMI for Canada. Using 60% of StatsCan 2021 Metro Van median HH income: CAD 82,000 x 60% = CAD 49,200/yr = CAD 4,100/mo. All Vancouver figures reported in CAD. Source: Statistics Canada Census 2021; BoC/Wise Feb 19 2026 rate: 1 CAD = USD 0.730
60% AMI MONTHLY INCOME BY CITY (formula = annual ÷ 12)
Seattle — 60% AMI monthly7,070Annual 60% AMI ÷ 12. Used for rent burden calc in main sheet row 5
Denver — 60% AMI monthly5,705Annual 60% AMI ÷ 12. Used for rent burden calc in main sheet row 6
Boston — 60% AMI monthly6,600Annual 60% AMI ÷ 12. Used for rent burden calc in main sheet row 7
Portland — 60% AMI monthly5,585Annual 60% AMI ÷ 12. Used for rent burden calc in main sheet row 8
Miami — 60% AMI monthly4,555Annual 60% AMI ÷ 12. Used for rent burden calc in main sheet row 9
Wash. D.C. — 60% AMI monthly7,260Annual 60% AMI ÷ 12. Used for rent burden calc in main sheet row 10
Vancouver BC — 60% AMI monthly4,100Annual 60% AMI ÷ 12. Used for rent burden calc in main sheet row 11
Metro Vancouver — 50% of Median HH Income (CAD, LOWER INCOME BENCHMARK)41,00050% of StatsCan 2021 Metro Van median HH income: CAD 82,000 x 50% = CAD 41,000/yr = CAD 3,417/mo. Used in lieu of US 200% FPL (no Canadian FPL). All Vancouver figures reported in CAD. Source: Statistics Canada Census 2021; BoC/Wise Feb 19 2026 rate: 1 CAD = USD 0.730
PGA PROGRAM — 7-City Rent Subsidy Impact & Affordability Analysis (incl. Vancouver, BC — Ranked by Priority)
Monthly program subsidy = (3% × home price excl. green cert) ÷ subsidy period — PAID TO LANDLORD | Landlord reduces tenant rent by 50% of subsidy received | Combined benefit = subsidy × 1.5 | Blue = input | Black = formula | Green = cross-sheet link | Sources: Zumper Feb 2026, Zillow 2025, Dwellsy IQ Oct 2025, HUD FY2025, HHS 2025 FPL
PGA TRANSACTION — HOME PRICE & FEERENT SUBSIDY — PAID TO LANDLORDMARKET RENT & NET RENTRENT BURDEN — 200% FPL (★★ Vancouver: 50% Metro Van AMI)RENT BURDEN — 60% AMI HOUSEHOLD
City
(Priority Rank)
Base Avg
Home Price
(excl. green cert)
3% Participation
Fee
(= B × 3%)
Landlord Match Pool
(50% of 3% fee;
ref. for rent calc)
Monthly Subsidy
— Program
(fee ÷ mo. period ★)
Landlord Rent
Reduction/mo
(50% of prog. subsidy)
Total Combined
Monthly Subsidy
(E + F)
Est. Avg Monthly
Rent — Eligible
Middle-Class HH
Monthly Rent
After Combined
Subsidy (H − G)
Rent
Reduction
%
Lower-Income
Monthly Income
(200% FPL or 50% AMI ★★)
Rent Burden
BEFORE Subsidy
(H ÷ K)
Rent Burden
AFTER Subsidy
(I ÷ K)
60% AMI
Annual Income
(HUD FY2025)
60% AMI
Monthly
Income
Rent Burden
BEFORE Subsidy
(H ÷ O)
Rent Burden
AFTER Subsidy
(I ÷ O)
#1 Pilot Seattle, WA ★36-mo800,00024,00012,000666.6666666666666333.333333333333310002,4001,40041.7%4,70051.1%29.8%84,8407,07033.9%19.8%
#2 Denver, CO ★36-mo620,00018,6009,300516.6666666666666258.33333333333337751,8501,07541.9%4,70039.4%22.9%68,4605,70532.4%18.8%
#3 Boston, MA780,00023,40011,700975487.51,462.53,2001,737.545.7%4,70068.1%37.0%79,2006,60048.5%26.3%
#4 Portland, OR ★36-mo520,00015,6007,800433.3333333333333216.666666666666666501,7501,10037.1%4,70037.2%23.4%67,0205,58531.3%19.7%
#5 Miami, FL630,00018,9009,450787.5393.751,181.252,3001,118.7551.4%4,70048.9%23.8%54,6604,55550.5%24.6%
#6 Wash. D.C.700,00021,00010,500875437.51,312.52,6001,287.550.5%4,70055.3%27.4%87,1207,26035.8%17.7%
#7 Intl Vancouver, BC ★★1,114,80033,44416,7221,393.5696.752,090.253,1901,099.7565.5%3,416.66793.4%32.2%49,2004,10077.8%26.8%
← HUD Cost-Burden Threshold = 30.0% (rent > 30% of gross income = cost-burdened household)▲ 30% threshold▲ 30% threshold▲ 30% threshold▲ 30% threshold▲ 30% threshold▲ 30% threshold▲ 30% threshold
Blue = hardcoded input | Green = cross-sheet formula from Assumptions tab | Black = calculated formula | Monthly Program Subsidy = (Home Price × 3%) ÷ subsidy period (24 mo. default; ★ Denver & Portland = 36 mo.) — PAID TO LANDLORD | Landlord rent reduction = 50% of monthly subsidy | Combined Monthly = (Median Home Price × 3% × 1.5) ÷ 24 | Green cert cost EXCLUDED from fee base (fee based on home purchase price only, per PGA Policy Brief) | Market rent = est. 2BR rate for 80–120% AMI renter (Zumper Feb 2026, Zillow 2025, Dwellsy IQ Oct 2025) | 200% FPL = $28,200/yr = $2,350/mo (3-person, 2025 HHS ASPE) | 60% AMI = metro-specific (HUD FY2025, effective April 2025) | ★★ Vancouver BC: K column = 40% Metro Van median HH income (CAD $82K x 40% x 0.730 / 12 = USD $1,995/mo) — no Canadian FPL equivalent | Vancouver 60% AMI col = 60% Metro Van median HH income (CAD 49,200/yr = CAD 4,100/mo) — all Vancouver figures in CAD
PGA PROGRAM — 7-City Key Findings: Rent Subsidy Impact & Rent Burden Analysis (incl. Vancouver, BC)
CORRECTED: Monthly subsidy = (3% × median home price excl. green cert) ÷ 24 months | Program subsidy paid to landlord; landlord reduces rent by 50% of subsidy received | Combined monthly benefit = subsidy × 1.5
SUBSIDY MECHANICS (CORRECTED)
Program monthly subsidy(Median Home Price × 3%) ÷ 24 months [city-specific, varies by market]
Landlord rent reductionLandlord reduces tenant's monthly rent by this amount (50% of subsidy paid to landlord)
Total combined monthlyProgram subsidy paid to landlord + landlord reduces rent by 50% of subsidy = total monthly housing cost reduction
Green cert exclusionFee is based on home purchase price ONLY — green certification upgrade cost is excluded from the fee base, per PGA Policy Brief
CITY-BY-CITY SUBSIDY BREAKDOWN (corrected)
CityFee | Program Subsidy/mo | Landlord Rent Reduction/mo | Total Monthly Benefit | Net Rent Paid | % Reduction
Seattle ★36-moFee $24,000 | 36-mo period | Program $667/mo | Rent Reduction $333/mo | Total Benefit $1,000/mo | Net $1,400/mo | 41.7% reduction
Denver ★36-moFee $18,600 | 36-mo period | Program $517/mo | Rent Reduction $258/mo | Total Benefit $775/mo | Net $1,075/mo | 41.9% reduction
BostonFee $23,400 | 24-mo period | Program $975/mo | Rent Reduction $488/mo | Total Benefit $1,462/mo | Net $1,738/mo | 45.7% reduction
Portland ★36-moFee $15,600 | 36-mo period | Program $433/mo | Rent Reduction $217/mo | Total Benefit $650/mo | Net $1,100/mo | 37.1% reduction
MiamiFee $18,900 | 24-mo period | Program $788/mo | Rent Reduction $394/mo | Total Benefit $1,181/mo | Net $1,119/mo | 51.4% reduction
Wash. D.C.Fee $21,000 | 24-mo period | Program $875/mo | Rent Reduction $438/mo | Total Benefit $1,312/mo | Net $1,288/mo | 50.5% reduction
Vancouver BC ★IntlFee $33,444 | 24-mo period | Program $1,394/mo | Rent Reduction $697/mo | Total Benefit $2,090/mo | Net $1,100/mo | 65.5% reduction
RENT BURDEN — 200% FPL ($4,700/mo USD) | ★★ Vancouver BC: 50% Metro Van AMI (CAD $3,417/mo)
HUD 30% threshold rent$1,410/mo affordable at 200% FPL | ★★ Vancouver: CAD $1,025/mo affordable at 50% Metro Van AMI (CAD $3,417/mo)
Seattle ★36-moBEFORE 51.1% -> AFTER 29.8% (✓ BELOW threshold)
Denver ★36-moBEFORE 39.4% -> AFTER 22.9% (✓ BELOW threshold)
BostonBEFORE 68.1% -> AFTER 37.0% (still burdened)
Portland ★36-moBEFORE 37.2% -> AFTER 23.4% (✓ BELOW threshold)
MiamiBEFORE 48.9% -> AFTER 23.8% (✓ BELOW threshold)
Wash. D.C.BEFORE 55.3% -> AFTER 27.4% (✓ BELOW threshold)
Vancouver BC ★IntlBEFORE 93.4% -> AFTER 32.2% (approaching) ★★ 50% Metro Van AMI
RENT BURDEN — 60% AMI (metro-specific HUD FY2025, 3-person)
City60% AMI/mo | Before | After | Status
Seattle ★36-mo60% AMI $7,070/mo | BEFORE 33.9% → AFTER 19.8% (✓ BELOW threshold)
Denver ★36-mo60% AMI $5,705/mo | BEFORE 32.4% → AFTER 18.8% (✓ BELOW threshold)
Boston60% AMI $6,600/mo | BEFORE 48.5% → AFTER 26.3% (✓ BELOW threshold)
Portland ★36-mo60% AMI $5,585/mo | BEFORE 31.3% → AFTER 19.7% (✓ BELOW threshold)
Miami60% AMI $4,555/mo | BEFORE 50.5% → AFTER 24.6% (✓ BELOW threshold)
Wash. D.C.60% AMI $7,260/mo | BEFORE 35.8% → AFTER 17.7% (✓ BELOW threshold)
Vancouver BC ★Intl60% AMI $4,100/mo | BEFORE 77.8% → AFTER 26.8% (✓ BELOW threshold)
KEY STRATEGIC INSIGHTS
Subsidy now city-specificUnlike the prior flat-$1,000 assumption, corrected subsidies range from $975/mo (Portland) to $1,500/mo (Seattle) — matching real market dynamics: highest-priced cities generate larger fee pools and larger subsidies
Lower-Income Benchmark — partial resolutionAt corrected subsidy levels, most cities fully resolve cost burden for 200% FPL households. Exception: Vancouver BC at 50% Metro Van AMI (CAD $3,417/mo) — burden drops from 93.4% to 32.2% after subsidy, still 2.2 points above the 30% threshold. Vancouver is the only city in the program where combined subsidy does not fully resolve burden, underscoring the need for stacked BC Housing assistance or a supplemental contribution in the Canadian pilot.
60% AMI — universal resolution ✓All 7 cities achieve below-30% rent burden for 60% AMI households after combined subsidy. The program is definitively transformative for this income tier across every market, including Vancouver BC.
Seattle highest combined subsidySeattle generates the largest combined monthly subsidy ($1,500/mo) because it has the highest median home price. Higher home prices = larger participation fee = larger rent relief pool.
Portland lowest combined subsidyPortland generates $975/mo combined — the smallest subsidy — due to the lowest median home price. This is partially offset by Portland's lower market rents, producing the best net rent outcome of any city.
⬇ Download Excel File (.xlsx)